Coronet or feathers: identifying the type
The portrait settles it. Gobrecht's Liberty has her hair swept up in a bun under a coronet; Saint-Gaudens's wears a full feathered headdress. On the reverse, the first eagle opens its wings while holding arrows and a branch; the second stands upright on a bundle of arrows.
Then run a finger along the edge: reeding points to the Liberty type, raised stars to the Indian type (46 before 1912, 48 from that year on).
The motto IN GOD WE TRUST gives one last clue. The Liberty type only received it in 1866, so an earlier piece lacks it. Saint-Gaudens had dropped it from his design, which caused protests; Congress made it compulsory again in May 1908. Hence coins without a motto in 1907 and early 1908.
First checks and recorded fakes
Neither the Liberty nor the Indian type escaped the counterfeiters. Among the fakes described by NGC are a Liberty dated 1899 and an Indian dated 1912, struck in gold at the legal weight: weighing the coin therefore proves nothing on its own. What betrays them lies in the details: mushy or rounded relief, tiny raised lumps in the field, spikes on the rim, marks left when the dies were touched up.
Before showing the coin to a numismatist, a few checks at home weed out the crudest copies:
- Scales reading to a hundredth of a gram: expect about 16.7 g, slightly less if the coin has seen heavy circulation.
- Caliper: close to 27 mm.
- Magnet: gold does not respond; any pull means a fake.
- Ring: balanced on a fingertip and tapped gently, a solid gold coin keeps ringing; a dull note calls for caution but settles nothing.
- Anachronisms: a D mark before 1906, a CC mark after 1893, a motto on a pre-1866 Liberty or a reeded edge on an Indian are enough to rule the coin out.
The full method is set out in the guide how to spot a fake coin.
Three denominations, one design: measuring to decide
During the same period the US Mint used these designs on three denominations. Measuring weight and diameter ends the doubt:
- half eagle ($5): 21.6 mm for 8.359 g;
- eagle ($10): about 27 mm for 16.718 g;
- double eagle ($20): 34 mm for about 33.44 g.
The reverse also states the value, abbreviated as “TEN D.” on the Liberty type and spelled out, “TEN DOLLARS”, on the Indian type. The larger sibling of this coin has its own page, the $20 gold coin; other countries are gathered under foreign coins.
Where an eagle wears first
On the Liberty type the high points give way first: the tip of the coronet, the hair above the eye, then the strands above the coronet. On the reverse, the wing tips and the eagle's neck flatten before anything else.
The Indian type follows the same logic: check the most prominent relief first, the headdress feathers and the cheek, then the eagle. A ten-power loupe makes the job more reliable.
Many eagles have been worn as jewellery or cleaned. Under a loupe you can spot solder, an edge reworked with a file or a shine that is too even. Do not rub anything: the grading scale is explained in the guide grades of preservation, and the damage done by cleaning in cleaning a coin.