Skip to content
United States

The American $5 gold coin (half eagle)

United States · 1839-1929 · Gold

Written by the Maison Or & Bijoux Strasbourg team · updated

$5 Indian Head gold dated 1909, obverse with the feathered headdress$5 Indian Head gold, reverse with the standing eagle in incuse relief
Photos: Maison Or & Bijoux.
Specifications
CountryUnited States
MetalGold at 900‰ fineness, the rest copper
Weight8.359 g
Fine gold7.523 g
Diameter21.6 mm; 22.5 mm for coins dated 1839
Denomination5 dollars, known as the half eagle
Years struckCoronet: 1839-1908; Indian Head: 1908-1916, then 1929
MintsPhiladelphia (unmarked), Charlotte (C), Dahlonega (D, until 1861), New Orleans (O), San Francisco (S), Carson City (CC), Denver (D, from 1906)
EngraversChristian Gobrecht (Coronet); Bela Lyon Pratt (Indian Head)
EdgeReeded on both types

The half eagle is the United States $5 gold coin: 8.359 g of 900 fine alloy, 21.6 mm across. Two designs span the years 1839 to 1929. Christian Gobrecht first engraved a Liberty wearing a coronet, struck until 1908. Bela Lyon Pratt then replaced her with a Native American wearing a war bonnet of feathers, the whole design sunk below the surface of the metal, a technique used nowhere else in circulating American coinage. Since the edge is reeded on both types, the design, the date and the mint mark are what tell you something.

Identification

The American $5 gold coin (half eagle): how to recognise it

$5 Indian Head gold dated 1909, obverse with the feathered headdress

Obverse

Coronet (1839-1908): Liberty's profile facing left, hair tied in a bun, a coronet inscribed “LIBERTY”, thirteen stars in a ring and the date below. In 1839 the Charlotte and Dahlonega pieces carry their mint mark on this side, above the date. Indian Head (1908-1929): a Native American's head facing left under a feathered headdress, “LIBERTY” at the top, thirteen stars split on either side and the date below the neck; lettering and portrait are cut into the metal.

$5 Indian Head gold, reverse with the standing eagle in incuse relief

Reverse

Coronet: eagle with open wings, arrows and an olive branch in its talons, the legend “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” and the abbreviated value “FIVE D.”. The “IN GOD WE TRUST” scroll is added above the bird in 1866. From 1840 the mint mark sits below the eagle, just above “FIVE D.”. Indian Head: an eagle standing on a bundle of arrows, with an olive branch, “E PLURIBUS UNUM” on the left, “IN GOD WE TRUST” on the right and “FIVE DOLLARS” at the bottom. The mint mark, left of the arrowheads, is the only raised element on the coin.

Edge
Reeded, on the Coronet and the Indian Head alike: the edge cannot tell the two types apart.
Engraver
The Coronet is by Christian Gobrecht. The Indian Head is the work of Bela Lyon Pratt, a Boston sculptor trained under Augustus Saint-Gaudens; the incuse relief had been suggested by the physician and collector William Sturgis Bigelow, with the backing of President Theodore Roosevelt.
Dates and mintages

The American $5 gold coin (half eagle): key dates

To place a half eagle, note its date first, then its mint mark. The letter D needs care: up to 1861 it stands for Dahlonega, Georgia; from 1906, for Denver. A coin with no letter comes from Philadelphia. The table gathers landmarks, not every date.

The American $5 gold coin (half eagle): dates and mintages
YearTypeMintMintageRemarks
1839CoronetCharlotte and DahlonegaunknownMint mark on the obverse, above the date: a one-off within this type.
1840CoronetNew OrleansunknownFirst half eagles marked O; the diameter drops to 21.6 mm.
1854CoronetSan Francisco268Struck on the mint's second day of production; four pieces known.
1861CoronetDahlonega1,597Before the Confederate seizure; Charlotte and Dahlonega both stop that year.
1866CoronetPhiladelphia and San FranciscounknownThe motto IN GOD WE TRUST arrives.
1870CoronetCarson CityunknownFirst half eagle marked CC.
1875CoronetPhiladelphia200Lowest business-strike mintage of the type; fewer than ten known.
1906CoronetDenverunknownFrom now on D means Denver.
1908Indian HeadPhiladelphiaunknownThe incuse design reaches pockets towards the end of the year.
1909Indian HeadNew Orleans34,200Lowest mintage of the series and the mint's very last half eagle.
1911Indian HeadDenverunknownRanked by David Akers just behind the 1909-O for rarity.
1916Indian HeadSan FranciscounknownLast striking before a twelve-year pause.
1929Indian HeadPhiladelphia662,000Mostly held in reserve, then melted after 1933.

Mintage sources: Collectors Key (1854-S, 1861-D, 1875, 1909-O, 1929); Wikipedia gives 668,000 for 1929. Opening and closing years of the mints from Collectors Key and Wikipedia. Partial selection.

Coronet or feathers: recognising the type

No point checking the edge: it is reeded either way. The face is enough. Gobrecht's Liberty wears a coronet and a bun, in ordinary raised relief; Pratt's Native American, in a feathered headdress, is instead sunk into the blank, so the smooth field is the highest part of the coin.

On the reverse, the Coronet's open-winged eagle contrasts with the Indian Head's resting eagle, perched on a bundle of arrows. The value helps as well: “FIVE D.” on the first, “FIVE DOLLARS” spelled out on the second.

Finally, a Coronet without IN GOD WE TRUST predates 1866. The Indian Head always carries the motto.

An incuse design questioned from 1908

The idea came from William Sturgis Bigelow, a Boston physician and friend of Theodore Roosevelt, who had noticed this sunken relief on Egyptian carvings at the Boston Museum of Fine Arts. He suggested to the president that Bela Lyon Pratt be given the design. The coins came out towards the end of 1908 and took people by surprise.

In December 1908 the Philadelphia numismatist Samuel Chapman wrote to Roosevelt that the recesses would hold dirt and germs, that the coins would stack badly and be easy to counterfeit, and that the Indian looked emaciated. Bigelow replied that the portrait came from a recent photograph of a man in excellent health.

The principle matters for wear: on the Indian Head it is the flat surfaces of the field that rub first, not the portrait.

Checks and reported fakes

NGC ranks the $2.50 and $5 Indian Heads among the hardest series to authenticate. It receives large numbers of fakes struck from one shared “stock” reverse die, dated 1909, 1913, 1915 or 1916 with an S mint mark: on these copies the S has stretched ends and blurred serifs, whereas the genuine letter has bulbous, almost square serifs. NGC also examined a supposed 1919, in fact a 1913 whose last digit had been reworked; the sunken date makes this kind of tampering easier.

At home, a few simple steps already weed out crude copies:

  • Scales reading to a hundredth: about 8.36 g, a little less for a heavily worn coin.
  • Caliper: 21.6 mm (22.5 mm for 1839).
  • Magnet: gold is not attracted; a coin that sticks is fake.
  • Impossible dates: no Indian Head was struck between 1917 and 1928 or after 1929.
  • Mismatched letters: O on an Indian Head other than 1909, CC after 1893, C after 1861.

The right weight proves nothing by itself. The full method is set out in the guide how to spot a fake coin.

$2.50, $5 or $10: let the ruler decide

Pratt drew the same Indian for two denominations, and Gobrecht's Liberty appeared on several coins. Size removes any doubt:

  • quarter eagle ($2.50): 18 mm, 4.18 g;
  • half eagle ($5): 21.6 mm, 8.359 g;
  • eagle ($10): about 27 mm, 16.718 g.

The $5 Coronet has one distinction: according to Wikipedia, it is the only American coin of a single design to have come from seven mints. Its bigger sibling has its own page, the $10 gold coin, as does the $20 gold coin. For the grading scale, see the guide grades of preservation; and never rub a coin, as cleaning a coin explains.

In Strasbourg

The American $5 gold coin (half eagle) in Alsace

Between Alsace and the dollar, the link is called Castroville. On 1 September 1844 Henri Castro, consul general of the Republic of Texas in France, settled several dozen families there from the Mulhouse area and neighbouring Baden. Nicknamed the “Little Alsace of Texas”, the town spoke Alsatian at home and in its shops for its first century; in 2018 fewer than fifteen residents still used it. It is twinned with Ensisheim. These settlers arrived five years after Gobrecht's first half eagles, though no source says they ever handled one. In Alsatian estates the coin is more likely to sit beside the $10 gold coin or the 20 marks gold coin.

The American $5 gold coin (half eagle): frequently asked questions

Where does the name half eagle come from?

The coin is worth half an eagle, the $10 gold piece. The United States has struck it since 1795: it was the country's first gold coin.

My $5 has a D: Dahlonega or Denver?

Look at the date. Up to 1861 the D means Dahlonega, Georgia; from 1906, Denver. In between, no half eagle carries a D.

Is there a $5 Indian Head dated 1920?

No. The type was struck from 1908 to 1916, then one last time in 1929. Any other date points to an altered or fake coin.

Why is the Indian Head design sunk into the coin?

The collector William Sturgis Bigelow took his cue from Egyptian sunken reliefs. Roosevelt backed the idea and Bela Lyon Pratt produced the design in 1908.

Is the right weight enough to rule out a fake?

No: NGC describes copies struck from imitation dies. The shape of the mint mark, the date and the design matter as much as the scales.