Skip to content
United States

The American $2.50 gold coin (quarter eagle)

United States · 1840-1929 · Gold

Written by the Maison Or & Bijoux Strasbourg team · updated

$2.50 Indian Head gold dated 1915, obverse with the feathered headdress$2.50 Indian Head gold, reverse with the standing eagle in incuse relief
Photos: Maison Or & Bijoux.
Specifications
CountryUnited States
MetalGold at 900‰, the rest copper (from 1837)
Weight4.18 g
Fine gold3.762 g (0.12094 troy oz)
Diameter18 mm from 1840 to 1929
Denomination2½ dollars, known as the quarter eagle
Years struckLiberty Head: 1840-1907; Indian Head: 1908-1915, then 1925-1929
MintsPhiladelphia (no letter), Charlotte (C, until 1860), Dahlonega (D, until 1859), New Orleans (O, until 1857), San Francisco (S, 1854-1879), Denver (D, 1911, 1914 and 1925)
EngraversChristian Gobrecht (Liberty Head); Bela Lyon Pratt (Indian Head)
EdgeReeded

Worth two and a half dollars, a quarter of the $10 eagle, the quarter eagle was the smallest regular gold coin of the eagle family in the twentieth century. From 1840 to 1929 it weighs 4.18 g at 900 fineness and measures 18 mm. Two designs share the period: Christian Gobrecht's Liberty in a coronet until 1907, then Bela Lyon Pratt's Native American, whose design is hollowed into the blank. The value is spelled out on the reverse, so the coin is hard to mistake for its larger siblings; the date and the mint mark do the rest.

Identification

The American $2.50 gold coin (quarter eagle): how to recognise it

$2.50 Indian Head gold dated 1915, obverse with the feathered headdress

Obverse

Liberty Head, or Coronet (1840-1907): Liberty's bust looking left, a coronet reading “LIBERTY”, hair held in a bun, a ring of thirteen stars and the date at the bottom. Indian Head (1908-1929): a Native American in profile facing left under a feathered headdress, “LIBERTY” above, stars along the rim and the date below the bust; the engraver's initials “BLP” sit just above the date. On this second type the whole design lies below the field.

$2.50 Indian Head gold, reverse with the standing eagle in incuse relief

Reverse

Coronet: a heraldic eagle with a shield, holding an olive branch and arrows, the legend “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” and the value “2 1/2 D.”. The mint mark is placed below the eagle. Unlike the larger gold coins of the same design, this reverse never received the motto “IN GOD WE TRUST”. Indian Head: an eagle standing on a bundle of arrows, an olive branch, “E PLURIBUS UNUM” and “IN GOD WE TRUST” on either side, “2 1/2 DOLLARS” at the bottom; the Denver D, where there is one, sits left of the arrowheads.

Edge
Reeded on both types. The Indian Head has no raised rim, a result of the incuse design.
Engraver
Christian Gobrecht for the Liberty Head, whose reverse may have been revised by Robert Ball Hughes according to Walter Breen. Bela Lyon Pratt, a Boston sculptor, for the Indian Head, on an idea of William Sturgis Bigelow backed by Theodore Roosevelt; Chief Engraver Charles Barber altered the eagle before striking, to Pratt's displeasure.
Dates and mintages

The American $2.50 gold coin (quarter eagle): key dates

A quarter eagle is placed by its date and its mint mark, which Philadelphia coins lack. Watch the D: before 1860 it means Dahlonega, Georgia; on an Indian Head it can only be Denver. The table offers a few landmarks rather than the full list.

The American $2.50 gold coin (quarter eagle): dates and mintages
YearTypeMintMintageRemarks
1840Liberty HeadPhiladelphia, Charlotte, DahlonegaunknownFirst year of Gobrecht's design; the mint mark moves to the reverse.
1841Liberty HeadPhiladelphiaunknownKnown only in proof, missing from the mint's records; roughly 14 to 18 pieces.
1848Liberty HeadPhiladelphia1,389CAL. counterstamp on the reverse: gold sent from California.
1854Liberty HeadSan Francisco246About a dozen survivors, all circulated.
1859Liberty HeadDahlonegaunknownLast quarter eagle from Dahlonega.
1875Liberty HeadPhiladelphia400Very low business-strike mintage.
1907Liberty HeadPhiladelphiaunknownFinal year of Gobrecht's design.
1908Indian HeadPhiladelphiaunknownReleased in November to a cool public reception.
1911Indian HeadDenver55,680Key date of the series; also found with a weak D.
1915Indian HeadPhiladelphia606,000Last year before a ten-year halt.
1925Indian HeadDenverunknownProduction resumes, at Denver only.
1929Indian HeadPhiladelphiaunknownEnd of a denomination struck since 1796.

Mintages: Collectors Key (1848 CAL., 1854-S, 1875, 1911-D); PCGS and CoinWeek (1915). Mint operating years from Wikipedia and Collectors Key. Partial selection.

Before Gobrecht: four designs in forty years

The Coinage Act of 1792 provided for the coin, but the first striking dates from 1796: a capped bust facing right, by Robert Scot, heavier (4.37 g) and wider (20.6 mm) than the coins covered here. Fewer than 20,000 pieces left the mint by 1807. John Reich turned the bust to the left in 1808, for a single year. Then came the capped head from 1821 to 1834, followed by William Kneass's Classic Head from 1834 to 1839, whose reverse lacks “E PLURIBUS UNUM”.

The Act of 1834 cut the weight to 4.18 g; the fineness settled at 900 in 1837. These early types are scarce, largely because so many were melted: of some 25,000 capped heads struck between 1829 and 1834, only 400 to 500 are thought to survive.

Liberty Head: sixty-eight years without the motto

Gobrecht's design stayed in use from 1840 to 1907, a record run for the denomination. The $5, $10 and $20 coins in the same style took on “IN GOD WE TRUST” after the Civil War; the quarter eagle never did. A $2.50 Liberty bearing that motto does not exist.

Five mints struck this type. The C, D and O letters vanish before the Civil War; San Francisco stops in 1879, leaving Philadelphia to carry on alone. Carson City never struck a quarter eagle: a CC on a coin this size gives away a fake.

One special case is the 1848 CAL.: California's military governor, Colonel R. B. Mason, sent about 230 ounces of gold-rush gold to the Secretary of War; the metal became 1,389 quarter eagles, punched “CAL.” above the eagle.

The Indian Head, cut below the surface

For the small denomination Pratt reused the half eagle design unchanged. Portrait and eagle are sunk in, so the flat field is the highest point of the coin and takes the knocks. According to Collectors Key, that field picks up bag marks easily, which makes high-grade pieces hard to find.

Production had its troubles: the blanks had to be shaved slightly to strike well, and the coins, thinner than their predecessors, upset sorting machines. The series has fifteen date and mint combinations, only three of them from Denver. Halted after 1915 amid the economic conditions of the First World War, it resumed in 1925, mainly to supply coins to give at Christmas, and ended in 1929. Franklin Roosevelt's measures of 1933 closed the denomination for good.

The 1911-D and other traps

With 55,680 pieces, the 1911-D is the key to the Indian Head series, and forgers know it. NGC examined a Philadelphia 1911, a common date struck in more than 700,000 pieces, on which a D had been carved with a tool: the letter was too thick, its serifs badly proportioned, and a loupe showed tool marks around it. Another fake 1911-D had been made by altering the date of a 1914-D. A word of caution, though: on many genuine 1911-D coins the D is weak and blends into the field.

NGC notes a paradox: the very common 1911 without a mint mark is counterfeited more often than the 1911-D, probably because its copies go unnoticed. First checks to make:

  • scales: 4.18 g, a little less if wear is heavy;
  • diameter: 18 mm;
  • magnet: no pull on gold;
  • dates: no Indian Head dated 1916 to 1924, no Indian Head marked O or S;
  • motto: never IN GOD WE TRUST on a Liberty Head.

These steps do not replace a look under magnification; the whole approach is in the guide how to spot a fake coin. The larger coin of the same design has its own page, the $5 gold coin.

In Strasbourg

The American $2.50 gold coin (quarter eagle) in Alsace

No record ties the quarter eagle to Alsace, where it was never legal tender. One strand of its story will still ring a bell in Strasbourg: when striking resumed in 1925 it was mainly to provide Christmas gifts, and the little gold coin was, according to Wikipedia, a popular present in the United States. Strasbourg has held its Christkindelsmärik, the “Christ Child market”, since 1570 and has styled itself “Capital of Christmas” since 1992. Nothing suggests quarter eagles were ever given here; in an Alsatian estate they may sit beside the $10 gold coin or the $20 gold coin.

The American $2.50 gold coin (quarter eagle): frequently asked questions

Why “quarter eagle”?

The eagle is the $10 gold coin; the $2.50 piece is worth a quarter of it. The name goes back to the American Coinage Act of 1792.

Is there an Indian Head quarter eagle dated 1920?

No. The type was struck from 1908 to 1915, then from 1925 to 1929. A date between 1916 and 1924 points to a fake or altered coin.

Should my $2.50 Liberty carry IN GOD WE TRUST?

It should not: the motto was never added to Gobrecht's quarter eagle, unlike the $5, $10 and $20 coins in the same style.

What does the CAL. mark on an 1848 coin mean?

It identifies a quarter eagle struck from the gold Colonel Mason sent from California at the start of the gold rush: only 1,389 pieces.

The D on my 1911 Indian Head is barely visible: is that a problem?

Not necessarily. Many genuine 1911-D coins have a weak D, and both NGC and PCGS recognise the variety. The details have to be judged together.